Alex Highsmith Out, ROLB Starter Up in the Air for Steelers vs. Ravens

OLB Alex Highsmith will not start for the Pittsburgh Steelers against the Baltimore Ravens, and it's up in the air as to who will replace him.

Pittsburgh Steelers depth chart OLB Preston Smith, Alex Highsmith, T.J. Watt Depth Chart
Pittsburgh Steelers outside linebackers Preston Smith, Alex Highsmith and T.J. Watt at practice on Nov. 8, 2024. -- Ed Thompson / Steelers Now

PITTSBURGH — Alex Highsmith will not be playing for the Pittsburgh Steelers at right outside linebacker against the Baltimore Ravens this Sunday, that much is assured, but whether it will be Nick Herbig or Preston Smith starting in his place, and the split of reps between them, remains to be seen.

Highsmith suffered a gruesome-looking left ankle injury late in the Steelers’ Week 10 win over the Washington Commanders two days ago, and is in a walking boot as he starts a recovery process that is expected to talk multiple weeks.

“You can characterize Alex Highsmith as out this week. We’ll take it week to week in terms of his availably,” head coach Mike Tomlin said on Tuesday. “We’re excited about getting him back to us ASAP. But he won’t be available this week.”

Highsmith’s father reported on X on Tuesday that the linebacker has a low ankle sprain, nothing is broken, and that he will be out two to three weeks.

Second-year outside linebacker Nick Herbig is expected to play after missing the last three games with a right hamstring injury. But how much Herbig plays, and whether or not he’ll start, or it will be recent trade deadline acquisition Preston Smith, remains to be seen.

Pittsburgh Steelers OLB Nick Herbig and T.J. Watt

“Pretty comfortable that Herbig is going to be back this week,” he said. “He was at the doorstep of it a week ago, so I think it’s reasonable to be able to include him.”

Herbig has been out for a while, with the injury occurring on Oct. 6. He was a limited participant in practice last week on Wednesday and Thursday before missing practice. So how much he’ll be available to the Steelers is still somewhat up in the air.

“It makes it even cooler that we have a guy like Preston Smith under those circumstances,” Tomlin said of the other option to start at right outside linebacker, but Smith comes with his own caveats. He has had just one week of practice with the team and may not have had a chance to absorb the entire playbook as installed, let alone anything new the Steelers may want to put in for Ravens week.

RELATED: Preston Smith Feels Right at Home in Steelers Defense

Smith also has not been playing a full workload with the Packers this season. He’s gone over 40 snaps just twice this season and actually played more snaps as a backup for the Steelers in Week 10 (23) than he had as a starter for the Packers in Week 9 (21).

So who will start and what will be the share of reps between Herbig and Smith?

“I have no idea,” Tomlin said. “Herbig’s not gotten himself fully in the boat yet, so I’d be speculating. … All of that will be determined after he gets really solid.”

Jeremiah Moon will once again be expected to serve as the team’s fourth outside linebacker. Moon played exclusively on special teams this past Sunday.

Pittsburgh Steelers Preston Smith

PITTSBURGH STEELERS INJURY REPORT

Player Injury Date  Prognosis Wed Thu Fri Game
WR Calvin Austin III TBD Nov. 10 Day to day PROB
RB Najee Harris Right ankle Nov. 10 Day to day PROB
CB Donte Jackson Hamstring Nov. 10 Day to day PROB
OLB Alex Highsmith Left ankle Nov. 10 Week to week OUT
OLB Nick Herbig Right hamstring Oct. 6 Day to day PROB

STEELERS INJURED RESERVE

Player Injury Date  Prognosis Roster Status
DT Montravius Adams Knee Oct. 18 Two weeks Injured reserve
CB Anthony Averett TBD Oct. 17 TBD Practice squad IR
WR Roman Wilson Hamstring Oct. 17 Two weeks Injured reserve
DE DeMarvin Leal Neck/stinger Oct. 6 Out for season Injured reserve
RG James Daniels Achilles Sept. 29 Out for season Injured reserve
CB Cory Trice Jr. Hamstring Sept. 22 Week to week Injured reserve
RT Troy Fautanu R knee dislocation Sept. 20 Regular season Injured reserve
P Cameron Johnston Right knee Sept. 8 Out for season Injured reserve
SS Ryan Watts Neck/stinger Aug. 24 Out for season Injured reserve
DL Logan Lee Calf Aug. 20 Week to week Injured reserve
C Nate Herbig Torn rotator cuff Aug. 14 Out for season Injured reserve
OLB David Perales Left MCL tear July 31 Out for season Injured reserve 
ILB Cole Holcomb Left knee surgery Nov. 2, 2023 Week to week PUP/reserve
Tags: