Analysis: Winners and Losers From Day 2 of Senior Bowl

MOBILE, Ala. — The Senior Bowl had yet another exciting day of practice on Wednesday. The National and American teams both had strong standouts and even losers from Tuesday rebounding in a big way. The action-packed day is impacting draft stocks for these players. Who is rising and who is dropping in Mobile?

Winner: Quinn Meinerz

No one was a bigger winner today than Wisconsin-Whitewater center/guard Quinn Meinerz. A Division III player, Meinerz came into the Senior Bowl with the opportunity to set his stock. In the past, Ali Marpet, Alex Cappa, and last year, Ben Bartch, all made claims and raised their stock as a result of their week in Mobile. Meinerz is doing the same.

At Wisconsin-Whitewater, Meinerz mauled defenders like it was nothing. It turns out that it is translating to the Senior Bowl. Meinerz threw Patrick Jones into the turf in the one-on-ones, mauled Osa Odighizuwa in the team session into the dirt, and otherwise a massive barrier. Meinerz lost maybe once the entire day in one-on-ones and was the best offensive lineman on the National squad today. In addition, he is getting great experience at center and showing he can do it at a high level. He is elevating himself into a Top-100 pick.

1/27/21 Practice SeniorBowl Photo by Jeff Hanson

Loser: Ian Book

The quarterbacks have not been too impressive this week. Mac Jones is clearly the best right now while Jamie Newman looks like the best from a physical tools perspective. Notre Dame quarterback Ian Book tried to make himself stick out on Wednesday by pushing the ball down the field. However, his arm just does not seem good enough as his balls fluttered and were erratic. In the short and intermediate game, Book was accurate. Still, it was offset by Book holding the ball for too long or bailing on clean pockets. In other words, Book looked liked he did at Notre Dame, which will put a cap on his draft stock.

Winner: Demetric Felton

On all points, Felton was another massive winner with a repeat performance from Tuesday. Working both as a receiver and running back, Felton toasted cornerbacks all day. A sweet whip route showcasing Felton’s quick feet and excellent hips was just the start of an impressive day. The highlight of Felton’s day was a double move that got Thomas Graham with a throw-by room to accelerate vertically. Even in the team session, Felton looked explosive in-between the tackles. He is proving he can do everything he is asked to do at a high level.

Loser: Rhamondre Stevenson

On the other side of the spectrum for running backs, Oklahoma running back Rhamondre Stevenson had a tough day. For such a big back pushing 230 pounds, it would be expected that Stevenson would be a high-level pass protector. However, Stevenson really struggled in pass protection drills on Wednesday. It seems to be largely a hand placement issue than anything, as Stevenson is getting controlled far too often. He did show some flashes of receiving ability, so it was not a complete loss, but Stevenson does have to better on Thursday.

Winner: Tylan Wallace

Perhaps the best receiver at practice today, Wallace put on a show. No one could cover Wallace one-on-one with his decisively crisp routes and releases. Wallace has made tough grabs with no separation but is separating with great footwork and physicality. It is the fact that he has won in multiple ways that should get scouts excited for Wallace’s showing. Wallace is showcasing that he is a complete receiver.

1/26/21 Practice SeniorBowl Photo by Jeff Hanson

Loser: Sage Surratt

After not playing all year, it was noticeable that Wake Forest receiver Sage Surratt has significant rust. He is not handling physicality well. That likely will change as he gets more comfortable. However, something that may not change is his inability to separate. He could not do it at Wake Forest and had to make contested catches consistently. The fact that he is not separating in the one-on-ones is concerning since contested catches are not super sustainable at the NFL level.

Winner: Richie Grant

The UCF safety has consistently been really solid all week. Grant has had a few high-quality reps in man coverage despite being a deep safety for most of his time with the Golden Knights. He has shown the ability to attack the catch point and the ball consistently all week. Add in the physicality and grit he has played with consistently and Grant is undoubtedly turning heads in a weaker safety class. Already a likely Top-100 pick, Grant can push into the Top-50 as he continues a strong week.

Loser: Hamilcar Rashed Jr

The standout Oregon State pass rusher came into with serious play strength concerns despite some obvious intriguing athletic traits. Listen, the burst is always going to be there for Rashed as a rusher. He is a natural mover in space and a nice athlete. However, he just does not have the hand usage or play strength to stack and shed blocks consistently. The fact that he does have lower half stiffness does not help when trying to reduce his surface area around the arc. Rashed may move to off-ball linebacker at the next level.

Winner: Tre Brown 

Here is a young man who is earning himself some cash this week. Tre Brown had an underrated, but solid showing on Tuesday, but on Wednesday he may have been the best cornerback on the National team. The Oklahoma cornerback has fantastic feet and lateral mobility. Brown mirrors receivers with great kick-step action. With an interception and multiple pass breakups in one-on-one action, Brown is rising in a big way coming out of Wednesday.

1/26/21 Practice SeniorBowl Photo by Jeff Hanson

Loser: Jamie Newman

Newman’s tools are incredibly intriguing. He has a howitzer for an arm and great mobility to create plays out of structure. The question is always consistency at every other level for Newman. Newman looked erratic with his accuracy and his footwork was a mess. More concerning, Newman did not seem to process the defense in any meaningful way, throwing multiple interceptions on the day due to inaccuracy and mental processing.

Winner: Tre McKitty

Maybe the most impressive tight end of the week, Georgia tight end Tre McKitty has dazzled scouts with numerous one-handed catches in the one-on-one drills. He has 11-inch hands, for the record. McKitty’s functional athleticism in space makes him a mismatch. He was not used heavily in that role at Georgia, but McKitty has all the tools to be a better receiver in the NFL than he was in college. His stock is going up.

Loser: Shaka Toney

After a decent showing on Tuesday, Shaka Toney took a step back on Wednesday. He was manhandled by Middle Tennessee State Tackle Robert Jones on an ill-fated spin move. Toney seemed to not have the anchor or play strength to take on bigger, more powerful guys and was washed on multiple reps in the team period as well. Overall, a down day for Toney who started off the week well.

Winner: Robert Jones

Speaking of Jones, what an impressive day this young man had on Wedsnesday. It was not just the stick of Toney that was impressive, albeit that was quite the highlight. It was the nimble feet and heavy hands that Jones showcased both at tackle and on the interior at guard that was impressive. Jones plays with good strength and has a lot of power behind his frame. His reps today should boost his stock greatly.

Alan Saunders provided reporting from Mobile.